Timeline and Concerns:
3/9/2017 - Church appointed as alternate board member at SVBGSA (groundwater sustainability agency). Form 700 discloses only antique business with McKenzie—no real estate, LLCs, or family ties mentioned, despite ~10-year relationship (dating back to ~2007). Forms are also patently incomplete.
4/20/2017 - Church marries Kathryn McKenzie after 10-year relationship. Marriage timing raises questions about pre-existing knowledge of McKenzie's LLC web (1995 cluster, ties to Burgstrom/Davis)—should have triggered immediate updated disclosures if any community property or influence existed.
9/2/2017 - Church's father dies.
10/12/2017 - Church leaves SVBGSA. In a 2022 campaign video, he claims he left due to a "bad experience" seeking term renewal (implying forced exit or rejection and no prior relationship evident) Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwqjAb_J_Bk (~3:00 mark). . No real estate listed on post-departure filings. filings patently incomplete. Verification and page count filled in by another Monterey County Leader.
Potential violations:
Penal Code § 118 (perjury if false statements on Form 700).
Gov. Code § 87200 et seq. (mandatory disclosure of economic interests); potential conflict under § 87100 if McKenzie's properties , the brokers they have a formal partnership with or any of their clients are related to water-dependent ag land, sanitation or any other issues that may have influenced SVBGSA decisions. Concerns about undisclosed spousal/relationship interests (Gov. Code § 87205 community property rules).
Other...
PAGE 1
Form suggest alternat board member but exit form suggests alternate Director.
Err - Omits A-1 While owning 10-100k in Pfizer Stock.
Err - Omits page count
Err - Omits all personal information (mailing address, phone and email)
A-1 - Stocks
n/a
Err - Missing Schedule A-1 - 10-100k in Pfizer stock. We know this from his exit filing. That said, it may belong to his wife and since they got married during this time window, may have been properly not reported.
PAGE 2
ERR - Lists Pacific Coast Soils as Sole proprietorship with 10-100k in income juxtaposition to 2 pages ater where it's listed as corporation at differnt adderss with less income.
NOTE: General descriptions - "Christmas Tree Farm" and <Blank> . compare to leaving office. No consistency.
NOTE: Avila construction
Err: Notes property for both businesses but does not provide address nor FMV
PAGE 3
Err - Illogically lists Pacific Coast Soils a 2nd time at different address with less income and notes it as a corporation. NOTE: General description is blank.
Err - List property for McKenzie Church but does not provide address or FMV. They owend property starting 9/26/2016
PAGE 4
APN provided aligns with 16729 CASTROVILLE BLVD SALINAS CA 93907.
APN and property not declared on departing form.
PAGE 5
He owns/manages a small water system. Relevant for other dialogue.
PAGE 1
Note: here he's leaving as Alternate Director, not board member. The same or different?
Err - page count was blank. Filled in improperly by Gary Peterson. Then director of Salinas Public Works.
Err - Verification details were blank. Filled in improperly by Gary Peterson. Then director of Salinas Public Works.
PAGE 2
Err - 10-100k in Pfizer stock not disclosed when accepting office , does not indicate it was purchased during encumbancy. does NOT state any income received -- yet then reports minor income on schedule C while claming it was his wifes/partners.
It may very well be hers. No way to know , but still missing the check to indicate he'd be filign income statement. Minor - but just another inconsitency.
PAGE 3
Err - Lists Pacific Coast Soils as Sole Proprietorship with 10-100k in income juxtaposition to later listing as corporation at differnt address with less income.
NOTE: General descriptions are "Christmas Trees" and "Landscape Materials, Consulting vs prior it was "Christmas Tree Farm" and <Blank> . No consistency.
Err Avila construction now gone No consistency
Err: Now no property associated with business contrary to 6 months ago. No Consistency.
PAGE 4
Err - Illogically lists Pacific Coast Soils a 2nd time at different address with different income and notes it as a corporation. NOTE: General description is NOT blank. Now it's "Landscaping Materials/Equipment".
Err - Now no property listed for McKenzie and Church. The owned property starting 9/26/2016 (or possibly prior)
PAGE 5
ERR - 377 not listed when assuming office and does not correspond to that APN. Why doesn't he use APNs now?
Err - 385 Hidden Valley property presented as if transferred as part of fathers death on 9/2/2017. However not in land records.
PAGE 6
Property transferred as result of fathers death. In land records.
PAGE 7
Again, just noting Hidden Valley Water association shows he owns/manages a small water system. for later referencde.
RE Pfizer - he discloses income without disclosing it on A1 - he marks it as spoused income (dividend).
Page 8
Err? - Disclosing a $500 gift card for what?